The Ultimate November Birthstone Buying Guide
Fall in Love with Your November Birthstone
How Much Do You Actually Know About November's Birthstone?
Did you know that people have been wearing golden topaz as a November charm for 1500 years?
Or that citrine was added as an alternate November birthstone back in 1952 when jewelers figured out how to make it cheaply by heating amethyst?
How about the fact that there is an awfully strong argument suggesting that amethyst is the real original November birthstone?
If you were born in November and you don't already love your birthstone, I think you will after you read this article. There is quite a story involved. Plus, your birthstone might not actually be the gem you think it is.
What is the November Birthstone?
This sounds like a simple question, and it is... kind of. The short and sweet answer is topaz. Specifically golden topaz. People have worn golden topaz as a November charm for 1500 years. But there are also several other gems that have strong claims to the status of "November birthstone".
If you already know that you love topaz, skip ahead to the Imperial Topaz Buying Guide.
That section will tell you everything you want to know before you go shopping, including:
Table of Contents
If you're not already in love with topaz, stick around.
There's a lot more to this story.
It turns out topaz isn’t your only November birthstone option. Citrine is a widely accepted alternate, and some truly unlikely candidates have valid claims to the title as well, including amethyst, emerald, garnet and aquamarine.
If you’re reading this you already know how special birthstone jewelry is. It makes a great personalized gift, especially when you take a loose gem and have a custom piece of jewelry made. Lately I’ve been seeing a lot of people designing rings for a loved one that feature their children’s or grandchildren’s birthstones. How much sweeter can you get?
Maybe you’re designing jewelry for yourself, or perhaps you’re shopping for someone else. Either way, getting the gemstone right is awfully important.
Here’s the thing… topaz is an AMAZING gem. It comes in an array of colors ranging from yellow to orange to red to pink and even purple.
But it isn’t your only option.
I’m going to lay out the history behind the November birthstone. You’ll see that you actually have quite a few choices, plus the story itself is wacky and fun to read. I’m also going to share a thorough buying guide to help you pick out topaz and citrine. We’ll cover everything from evaluating color, clarity and cut to potential treatments, durability factors and physical and energetic properties.
Finally, I’m going to tell you exactly where to go online to buy high quality, beautiful topaz, citrine and all the alternate November birthstones, both loose and set in jewelry.
That’s right. No more shopping around Etsy or Ebay, worrying about faked gemstones and unscrupulous dealers or jewelers. Just one solid list of reputable, reliable sources, so you can get on to the fun part - designing your jewelry or giving your gift.
Once you've read this guide, you will have every tool you need to find an amazing November birthstone for yourself or a loved one, PLUS you'll be well equipped to negotiate a killer deal on that stone. Let's jump on in.
What is the November Birthstone?
To get the full answer, we've got to go back about 3500 years...
Which is when the whole birthstone story starts. Where do birthstones come from? They're associated with the zodiac, which originated in India. I always assumed that birthstones came along with the zodiac, or perhaps they had their origins in some pagan tradition which would account for the mystical powers ascribed to them as sources of protection and bringers of luck.
Imagine my surprise when I learned that the whole birthstone tradition actually comes out of the… bible? Yup. Straight from the Old Testament.
According to scripture, back in the 13th or 14th century BC God instructed Moses to make a holy breastplate for his brother, Aaron the Priest, first high priest of the Israelites. The breastplate was to be inlaid with 12 gemstones, each representing one of the 12 tribes of Israel.
Okay, so we have a cool breastplate in the Old Testament, but what do the twelve tribes of Israel have to do with the zodiac?
As far as the original religious scholars were concerned, not a whole lot. But then, in the first century AD, a Jewish priest and historian by the name of Flavius Josephus started to speculate. He actually picks apart every material that went into that breastplate, investing each thread with divine meaning. About the gems Flavius wrote,
“And for the twelve stones, whether we understand by them the months, or the twelve signs of what the Greeks call the zodiac, we shall not be mistaken in their meaning.”
Flavius started the trend, and lots of ecclesiastical writers after him carried it on. For most of modern history, the fashion was to own all twelve gemstones and wear a different one each month. People believed each month’s gem would offer them protection and bring good fortune. The tradition of wearing just one “birthstone” may have originated in 18th century Poland, though some scholars believe it started even earlier, in the 1500’s in Germany.
We've got twelve stones, twelve months, people are wearing them, it seems like we know what's what, right? Here’s the twist…
What were the twelve birthstones in Aaron’s breastplate?
The answer to this simple question has been hotly argued by nerdy historians, priests and even royalty since at least the time of Flavius. The debate still rages today, with the Jewelers of America feeding fuel to the fire by adding new birthstones to the modern list every couple of years.
Let's sift through the last two millennia of debate and see if we can't find...
The Real November Birthstone
This is a three (at least) sided debate. I am going to make three different cases for three distinct gemstones that could qualify as the "real" November birthstone. I'll also show you a few alternate November birthstones along the way.
First: Could Amethyst be the Original November Birthstone?
The part of the old testament describing Aaron’s breastplate was originally written in Hebrew. Way back in the 2nd century BC, it was first translated into Greek. Based on this translation and what we know about gems from that era (if you want to know all the details, please read this footnote, the story is fascinating, and totally nerdy), here’s the original birthstones as recorded in the original Old Testament:
Doesn’t look very familiar does it? The months aren't even in the right order. That's because of a is a fun and little known fact: January didn't become the first month of the year until the 17th century.
Between the 6th and 10th century AD a whole slew of changes to the birthstone list were made by various writers, historians and even several members of various royal families. If you want a full history, a fellow calling himself Mornay of Anglesey, member of the Kingdom of Caid of the Society for Creative Anachronism (all I can say is look it up, it is worth a few minutes of reading) wrote a truly fascinating and thorough account. His research is impressive, and it brings us to the next gemstone that has a claim on the title "November birthstone".
Second: Topaz has been Recognized as the November Birthstone for over 1500 Years
Most of the other birthstones have changed repeatedly over the centuries, but the November birthstone only changed once. From roughly the 6th century on, topaz has appeared as the November birthstone on every list in the Western world.
How did we make the switch from amethyst to topaz?
I wish I had a more satisfactory answer here. Scholars aren’t certain if it was an error in copying, translation or an intentional edit, but at some point in the 800 years between the original Greek translation of the Old Testament and the birthstone list published by Isadore, Bishop of Seville in the late 6th century, topaz stole the title from amethyst.
One thing we can say for certain is that topaz held onto the title of November birthstone, despite a near constant shuffling of all the other birthstones.
Let’s fast forward to 1912, when the standardized birthstone list we use today was created by the National Association of Jewelers. They kept topaz on as the November birthstone. But over time, and fitting for our modern commercial world, they started to make a few edits to boost sales and profits. When a birthstone was too rare, expensive or difficult for jewelers to procure, they simply started adding alternates.
Third: Citrine is named as an Alternate November
Birthstone in 1952.
In 1952 is jewelers and gem dealers figured out how to apply heat and pressure to amethyst artificially to create citrine.
Untreated natural citrine is quite rare, but amethyst is very common and inexpensive. By treating amethyst, suddenly jewelers had an ample supply of a pretty yellow stone for a low price.
Before you write off citrine as an “impostor birthstone” due to its late and commercially motivated addition to the list, please consider two factors that help validate its claim:
A Case of Mistaken Identity: Until very recently we lacked the technology to reliably distinguish gemstones. Topaz was used to describe any yellow or golden gemstone for nearly 1000 years. It is quite certain that some of the “topaz” worn as a November birthstone charm throughout the ages was actually citrine.
All Citrine was Once Amethyst- When quartz contains enough iron inclusions it displays the gorgeous purple of amethyst. When amethyst is exposed to heat and pressure the iron oxidizes and the stone displays the warm colors of citrine. Amethyst was the “original” November birthstone, and citrine comes from amethyst, so maybe that gives it an edge.
As much as I would like to disparage the Jeweler’s Association for altering the birthstones for commercial purposes, it turns out that citrine has a valid claim on the November slot, even if most of the material on the market today was colored by man, not nature.
And citrine isn’t the only gem that qualifies as an alternative to topaz for the November birthstone.
Mystic Traditions Give Us Numerous Alternate
Aquamarine or Garnet for Scorpios, Topaz or Emerald for Saggitarians
The Zodiac has its origins with the Babylonians of Mesopotamia as far back as 3000 BCE. According to the Zodiac, two signs share the month of November. Those born between October 24th and November 22nd fall under Scorpio, a sign associated with aquamarine. From November 23rd to December 21st Saggitartius rules the Zodiac. The gemstone of Sagittarius is topaz.
The Moorish Zodiac is a little different. This practice, passed down through the descendants of Arab traders dating back to the 6th century AD, assigns garnet as the gemstone representing Scorpio, and gives Saggitarians emerald.
If you'd like to learn more about the zodiac, check out Jessica Lanyadoo's Instagram. She is super cheeky, and gives a detailed and totally entertaining introduction to astrology.
Cat’s Eye Gemstones Represent November in the Hindu Zodiac
While the West was shuffling its birthstone lists, India already had a rich tradition surrounding symbolism and gemstones. In Hindu cosmology gems are powerful, acting as a physical seat into which a deity can descend.
The fifth century text Ratnapariksa describes the intricate relationships between gems, planets, deities, months and even days of the week.
The Hindu tradition lists “Cat’s Eye” as the November birthstone. An optical phenomenon, called chatoyance, Cat's Eye occurs in many different types of gemstones. Most commonly this band of reflected light, which makes the polished surface of a cabochon (an unfaceted gem with a flat bottom and a polished top) look like the eye of a cat, is seen in chrysoberyl and tiger’s eye, though it can occur in tourmaline, moonstone, quartz and even emerald or sapphire.
If you choose to follow Hindu tradition and take Cat’s Eye as your birthstone, you can choose from any one of the wide range of gemstones that display chatoyance. However, you may care to know that according to the Ratnapariksa Cat’s Eye, along with sapphire, coral and ruby is considered capable of carrying malefic energies.
Alternately, topaz is considered a source of beneficent energy along with emerald, pearl and diamond.
There is another mystical tradition we can turn to as we seek to define the birthstone for November. There are a number of healers and individuals who call upon specific Guardian Angels to help them through life’s challenges. There is an angel associated with each month, and each angel has a talismanic stone, a gems that is believed to be imbued with the angel’s blessings and protection.
Amethyst, arguably the “original” November birthstone, is also the Talismanic stone of Adnachiel, November’s Guardian Angel.
There are a lot of good arguments for amethyst as the November birthstone. Between amethyst, emerald, garnet and cat’s eye gems you can choose nearly any color you like. However, it’s been my experience that most people do end up choosing the traditional colors associated with November.
Topaz and citrine are the only two November birthstones that have the warm golden and orange hues of fall.
So for the rest of this article I’m going to focus on these two gems.
I am about to tell you everything you need to know to pick out a topaz or citrine, how to negotiate an excellent price, and where to find reputable sellers.
I’ve included a list of reliable sources for the alternate November birthstones too. First, I’m going to give you the complete low-down on topaz. The tools I am about to give you to evaluate the quality of a topaz apply to other gemstones too, so it’s worth reading through this part even if you don’t think you want to buy topaz.
You can apply these tools and tips to any colored gemstone you are shopping for.
Here is Your Complete Topaz Buying Guide
You’ve probably seen blue topaz in every jewelry store you’ve ever entered. Blue, clear and white topaz is super common, but the warm colors you want in your November birthstone are as rare as blue topaz is prevalent.
You are looking for precious topaz (golden and orange-gold) or imperial topaz (red or reddish-orange). You could also choose a pink topaz.
All three, especially in their natural, untreated state, are incredibly rare gems.
I’m about to give you all the tools you need to shop for these gemstones. These tools will work whether you are working directly with a custom jeweler, buying a piece of pre-made jewelry or shopping for a loose gemstone. When we’re done, you’ll be fully prepared.
After reading this guide you’ll have the tools you need to evaluate the quality of a gem and negotiate a fair price.
If you are new to the colorful world of gemstones I strongly encourage you to read this entire guide. Having a thorough overview really will save you so much time and money when it comes time to shop.
That said, you are more than welcome to skip around and pick out the bits that are most useful to you. Here are the topics we’re going to cover next:
Topaz Buying Guide: Quick Navigation
Click on any of the headings below to jump to that section.
Etymology and History of Topaz
The internet will tell you that the word topaz comes either from the Sanskrit “tapas”, meaning fire, or from the island Topazius where topaz was originally mined. The first seems fitting, since topaz is known for its fiery glow, but the second is actually more likely. Except that most websites get the story wrong. Topaz was never mined on the island Topazius. So how did it end up with that name?
The Ancient Greeks called topaz “chrysolite” and chrysolite “topaz”.
There is an island in the Red Sea, Zabargad, that the Greeks called Topazius, meaning “to seek”. The tiny island was notoriously hard to find back in the day because it was often shrouded in fog. It’s really little, less than 2 square miles of rocky ground, located right where that red dot is on the map below.
The Greeks (and the Egyptians before them) did mine gems on this island, and they did name the gems “topaz” after the island. But the stones they mined were green, not yellow. The island was full of chrysolite (more commonly known as peridot), not topaz.
The same Greeks called the gems we know as topaz “chrysolite” meaning “golden stone”. The mysterious part is what happened next. How did we end up using “chrysolite” to describe green peridot, and “topaz” to describe a golden gem? That is a question I haven’t been able to answer yet, but when I figure it out I’ll let you know!
In the meantime, take a look at this awesome vintage Georgian pendant from Lang Antiques. It showcases pink topaz and peridot (the green stone). The color combination is beautiful, and knowing the intertwined history of the two gems makes it an especially cool piece, don’t you think?
What Color is Topaz?
For most of modern history we’ve ascribed fall colors to November: yellow, orange and red, and these are the colors typically associated with the November birthstone. I mentioned earlier that clear and blue topaz are quite common, and that they don’t fit this autumn color scheme, so we’re going to drop them for the rest of this article.
If you want to learn more about blue topaz, gemologist Hobart King wrote an excellent resource describing how blue topaz is made, and the Diamond Store offers a clear, precise buying guide for blue topaz.
The rest of this buying guide will focus on precious, pink and imperial topaz.
Those names, precious, pink and imperial, are trade names, which means you won’t see them written on any gemological lab report (those will just say “topaz”). These terms are used a bit subjectively by jewelers and gem dealers, so if you are shopping for topaz you need to have a basic understanding of what each one means.
Here’s the breakdown:
There is (almost) only one place on Earth where precious and imperial topaz are found.
Imperial topaz used to come from Russia. That’s where it got the name "imperial". The 17th century Russian emperors were so infatuated with the fiery colors of imperial topaz that they banned anyone but royalty from possessing it. Some of the most intense, vibrant and truly red imperial topaz in the world today came out of Russian mines.
Unfortunately, the Russian source dried up many years ago. A few savvy investors still have some rough they are waiting to cut, and a few others have a stash of cut gems, but for the most part if you want Russian imperial topaz you will have to seek out vintage stones. Ruby Lane has a relatively large selection, and both Cynthia Findlay in Toronto and Levy’s Fine Jewelry in Alabama usually have a few nice pieces.
Today, the only place that topaz with the brilliant red and orange Imperial coloring is found is Ouro Preto, Brazil. That’s right, just one town up in the mountains a few hours from Rio.
Nowhere else on Earth has this material. Well, almost nowhere else.
Quite recently imperial and pink topaz has been seen from the Katlang mine in Pakistan. Some beautiful pale pink gems do come out of this region, and brighter reds are occasionally found.
You should know that both pink and imperial topaz from Katlang are often treated to improve their color.
This doesn’t mean you shouldn’t buy Katlang topaz. It does mean you should do your homework, find out if the gem you are looking at is treated and negotiate a fair price, which is significantly lower for treated material.
After I tell you how to evaluate a gemstone for quality, I’ll explain the different treatments that you might see in topaz, how to identify a treated stone and how to negotiate with the dealer if you choose to buy such a gem.
First, whether a stone is treated or not, you need to know a little bit about the “Four C’s” of grading colored gemstones. This information can save you a ton of money.
I’m going to give you a simple 3 Step System to easily and QUICKLY evaluate the quality of any colored gemstone.
Then I’ll share some more detailed tools to help you negotiate the best price for your stone. Once you know these simple tools, even the most gifted salesman won’t be able to get you to overpay for a mediocre gem.
How do you know if the gemstone in your shopping cart is worth the price tag?
The “Four C's” dictate the value of any colored gemstone. They are: color, cut, clarity and carat. In just a moment we’ll dig into each of these and I’ll give you some simple tools to test any gemstone.
First, I want to share my simple, 3 Step System to easily and quickly evaluate the quality of any colored gemstone. Just ask yourself three simple questions:
Are you absolutely, completely in LOVE with the color? Really, truly. Does it
make you grin when you look at it?
Does the stone glow with internal fire and brilliance? Be strict here. Take the gem
into a dimly lit room - it should still dazzle.
Does light move evenly through the stone or do you see dark spots or
“holes” where you can see through the gemstone? This is a simple way to evaluate the cut of the gem.
You can follow these three steps when you’re shopping for a gem online, but to really make a decision you need to see a stone in person. Any reputable online gem or jewelry dealer will offer you a free return for at least 7-30 days after you receive your stone for this very reason.
Do not buy a gem from an online dealer who does not offer free returns.
If the gemstone passes all three tests, congratulations! You’ve found a nice gemstone. If a stone doesn’t pass these tests, keep looking. There are a lot of gems out there. Don’t spend your money on a stone that isn’t amazing.
Okay, so your gem passes the 3 Step System. Now let’s go a little deeper and help you get a great price on that stone.
I’m going to walk you through each of the Four C’s and teach you how to evaluate the quality of any colored gemstone.
All the gems pictured in the examples below are real gems from my store, Lockwood & Sloan. I use them in the examples to show you how topaz really looks when you’re shopping online.
The First “C”: Color is King when it comes to assessing the value of a colored gemstone.
Unlike diamonds, where cut is the most important factor, when you are shopping for any colored gem, color trumps everything else. You must love the color of your gem. This is so important.
You also need to consider where that color you love falls in the value spectrum for that type of stone. You might fall in love with a gem that has an “inferior” color according to this guide, and that’s okay! In fact, it’s awesome. You get a gem you love for less money.
The most valuable hue of topaz is pink or purple.
When we’re looking at precious, imperial and pink topaz, the value increases as we move through the following hues:
Yellow - Orange - Red - Pink - Purple
Don’t worry too much about the nuances of evaluating color. Even experienced gem dealers will disagree over slight variations in hue. Is the gem slightly orangey - yellow or is it strongly yellowish - orange? You’ll go crazy if you try to pick it all apart.
Just remember, yellow is cheaper than orange is cheaper than pink. Yellow, orange, pink.
Take a look at the image below - can you rank the precious topaz in order from least valuable to most valuable?* That’s all you need to be able to do.
Tone and saturation also affect the color and value of topaz.
Tone refers to how light or dark the color is, while saturation refers to how intense the color is. In general, you want a medium tone, so the gem is not too light or too dark.
Look at these stones:
These three topaz gems show the same golden hue in light, medium and dark tones. The center stone is the most valuable tone.
Saturation describes the intensity of the color. The more intense the color, the more valuable the gemstone. This is true of topaz and all other colored gemstones.
The hue of these two imperial topazes are both “slightly orangey red”, but the one on the right is far more saturated. In this case, the price rises by nearly $1000/ct because of the difference in saturation.
The Second “C”: The brilliance of the gemstone reveals the quality of the cut.
A well cut gemstone reflects light evenly. When you look down at it from the top, straight on, the entire surface should shimmer and bounce light back with no holes or dark spots.
You should also look more closely, examining the individual facets. The facets should meet at single points, not be offset. The bottom of the gemstone should also come to a clean point or line, without bulges or rounded surfaces.
This topaz was precision cut by master gem cutter Wayne Emery.
You can see the clean, sharp lines and facets, and the dazzling brilliance of the stone.
The topaz below was commercially cut.
The lines are not as clean and there are some bulges on the pavilion facets (on the bottom of the gem). From the top you can see an “empty” spot, or window. This gem is very pretty and will make a lovely ring, but it cannot demand the same high price as the precision cut gem above.
Remember, the most important thing is that you love your gemstone. The second most important thing is that you know where that gem falls in the quality of its color, cut and clarity so that you can negotiate the best price possible.
If you can tell the difference between the two gems above, you are well on your way to negotiating a great price on the next gem you buy.
The Third “C”: Clarity. Some inclusions are expected in natural precious and imperial topaz.
Precious and imperial topaz actually get their beautiful colors from teeny tiny chromium inclusions. As the color intensifies, you usually see more eye visible inclusions. In general, yellow topaz can be found quite clean, while the more orange and red stones tend to have more inclusions.
Very small inclusions that are not readily visible to the naked eye do not affect the value of a topaz.
However, if inclusions are large enough to detract from the beauty of the gem, the price must decrease, even for an imperial topaz. Look carefully for fractures that reach the surface of the gemstone, as these can affect its durability.
Inclusions in Imperial Topaz
The gem on the left has eye visible inclusions, which detract from its beauty and will bring the price down a bit, maybe 15-20%. It has awesome color (and color is king), so it is still worth a fair penny.
The gem on the right has a surface reaching fracture, which could affect its durability. This stone will be sold at bargain basement prices, and should be worn and cleaned with care.
Some inclusions can actually enhance the beauty of a gemstone.
Inclusions themselves can be beautiful, creating a pretty pattern or interesting texture in a gem. For many in the industry, inclusions are considered an important indication that the gem is natural. Many gemologists, jewelers and collectors seek out gemstones with unusual inclusions, as these are often more rare and unique than perfectly clean gems.
These three topaz gems show unique and compelling inclusions.
Beautifully Included Pink, Imperial and Golden Topaz
The Fourth “C”: Carat. As the size of pink, precious or imperial topaz increases, so does the per carat value.
Some gemstones, like blue topaz or amethyst, occur in gem quality in large sizes on a regular basis. These stones tend to cost the same dollar amount per carat, regardless of the size.
Other stones, like pink or imperial topaz, are very rare in large sizes, so their value increases dramatically as the carat value goes up. A 5 carat imperial topaz is worth 10 times more per carat than a 0.9 carat imperial topaz with the same color, cut and clarity. The biggest jump in price is right at the 1 carat mark. A gem under a single carat may only be $250/carat, but the 1.3 carat gem of the same quality sells for $1000/carat.
When you are shopping for topaz, look for gems that weigh in just under the 1, 3, or 5 carat marks. These are cut-off points in topaz pricing, so a gem just below any of these values will cost less per carat than a stone above them.
You can save a lot of money by purchasing a 2.9 carat gem instead of a 3 carat gem.
That’s your crash course in the Four C’s of Gem Grading for topaz. Here’s a cheat sheet to help you remember how to use the Four C’s to find the perfect topaz gemstone AND get it for a great price.
Treatments: An untreated gemstone is always more valuable than a treated gem.
Now that you know how to assess a topaz based on the Four C’s, you’ll be able to pick out some great gems (and get them for a good price!). But there is one more factor you need to be aware of - gemstone treatments.
There are a variety of ways that miners, dealers and jewelers can alter the appearance of rough or cut gemstones. You may have heard of “heat treatments” which can alter the color of a gemstone (that’s how blue topaz gets its bright blue color) or of “oiling”, a technique commonly used on emeralds, where fractures in the stone are filled in with oil to improve the clarity.
Blue topaz is made by irradiating yellow, brown or clear topaz and then heating it. Mystic topaz is made by a metallic coating that is laid on top of a clear stone.
As far as precious, pink and imperial topaz go, there are three treatments that you might come across:
Heat can be applied to a yellow topaz, turning it pink. The pink color is stable and won’t fade with time.
Irradiation can make topaz display red-orange imperial colors. This treatment is not stable, so irradiated gems will fade over time, especially if they are exposed to the sunlight. This is a very common treatment with imperial topaz from Katlang and other Pakistan mines.
This last is one that makes me ashamed of the industry. Most of us, gem dealers, jewelers and miners, are good honest people. But it only takes a few bad eggs to create a lot of distrust. Okay, so here it is. Sometimes you’ll see pink topaz online that is SUPER CHEAP. They are usually vibrantly pink. These stones are either coated or dyed clear topaz, or they are not topaz at all. Pink topaz is rare and valuable. If the price looks “too good to be true” IT IS.
Gem dealers and jewelers are required by law to disclose any treatment that significantly affects the value of the gem.
For many years there has been an ethical guideline in the industry requiring dealers and jewelers to disclose ALL gemstone treatments. This practice was required by Jewelers of America (the same folks who created our modern birthstone list) and by the American Gem Trade Association (AGTA). Basically any reputable dealer or jeweler who wanted to keep a decent reputation in the industry had to disclose treatments.
Now this practice is actually required by law. Unfortunately, there are still scummy people out there, and in the online age it is all too easy for them to advertise their products.
There are four things you can do to protect yourself:
First, ask for an independent gem certificate. This is a certification from an organization outside of the seller, maybe GIA, NAGL or IGS. These can be useful, but gemologists can also miss things, get lazy or make mistakes. A gem certificate is a tool to help guide your decision. It is not gospel.
Second, investigate the seller. This is the single best thing you can do to protect yourself from unethical folks. Dig around on their website. Do they have industry connections? Can they track the gemstone you are buying all the way back to the mine it came from? What is your gut feeling about them? Ask them questions, start a conversation.
Use what you know about the Four C’s to gauge their honesty. “I notice the facets on this stone aren’t quite even” or “This gem is pretty, but the color isn’t very intense. Why is it priced the same as this other stone with better color?” The way the seller answers these questions will tell you a lot about their business ethics.
Finally, never buy a gem that doesn’t come with a no-questions-asked money back guarantee. You should be able to see it in person, take it to an independent gemologist if you choose and send it back if it is not exactly what you expected.
Natural vs. Untreated Gemstones
As a side note, you should be aware that “natural” and “untreated” are very different terms. A natural gem is one that formed in the earth, as opposed to a synthetic gem that is manufactured in a lab.
Treatments can be applied to either natural or synthetic gems. There is not currently any synthetic topaz. Sometimes you’ll see imitations, glass, citrine, or quartz being sold as topaz. While this is terribly dishonest and a deplorable practice, these imitations are natural stones, not synthetics.
Now you really have all the information you need to go shopping for topaz. You know how to evaluate the quality of a stone based on its color, cut, clarity and carat weight, which gemstone treatments to look for and how to use this knowledge to negotiate a fair price or choose a reputable gem dealer.
You are ready to find your perfect November birthstone. You have what you need to go shopping, but there are a couple more things you may enjoy knowing about topaz.
For those of you feeling a bit nerdy, I’ve put together a list of the basic physical properties of topaz.
Caring for Topaz Gems and Jewelry
For those of you feeling a bit mystical, topaz is associated with specific energetic healing properties.
These associations take us way back in history. The Ancient Egyptians and Romans both linked topaz with their respective sun gods, Ra and Jupiter respectively, and believed that wearing topaz offered the protection of that god.
Greeks believed topaz made the wearer strong and even invisible (!!), and that it changed color in the presence of poisoned food or drink. I feel like those last two would have been pretty easy to disprove, don’t you?
In Renaissance Europe people used topaz to break magic spells, while in India they’ve worn it for centuries above the heart to bring the wearer intelligence, beauty and longevity. In China yellow shades of topaz in particular are considered very lucky.
The modern crystal healers of the Western world recognize topaz, and other silicates, as “enhancement crystals”. These gems help you clarify your goals and dreams so you can take the appropriate actions to manifest them. Topaz in particular supports the crown chakra, helping you connect to your divine path and honing your intuition.
Topaz has a rich history as a healing crystal. It is also fun to note that the habit of wearing just your own birthstone is relatively new. Up until the 18th century people wore each stone in its own month to bring good fortune. According to this tradition, wearing topaz in November should bring luck, clarity, beauty, intelligence and so on to anyone, not just those born in November.
Whether you plan to enjoy either the mystical healing properties or simply the stunning beauty of a topaz gemstone, you should know how to care for it properly.
Topaz is a durable stone. Only corundum (ruby and sapphire) and diamond are harder than topaz, making it a strong gemstone suitable for all types of jewelry. It holds up well to daily wear and can be used in rings. Just be a little careful about exposing it to direct impacts. Due to it’s perfect basal cleavage plane, topaz can be split in two by a strong blow.
Clean topaz with mild liquid soap, water and a soft toothbrush. It is a good idea to have all your fine jewelry professionally cleaned on a regular basis (regular varies depending on how much you wear it, but once or twice a year is probably plenty). Store topaz jewelry wrapped in a soft cloth, out of contact with other gems. Topaz will scratch softer stones, including amethyst, and can be scratched by sapphire, ruby or diamond.
Well, short of taking you to the mine or introducing you to my gem cutter, I think I’ve told you everything you’ll find of interest about topaz. If I haven’t, please leave a comment below and I’ll do my best to tell you whatever it is you’d like to know.
Next is a brief Citrine Buying Guide, and then I’ll give you a complete list of places to buy November birthstone gems and jewelry online. These are all reputable, reliable dealers you can trust to give you accurate information and fair prices.
First let’s take a quick look at the factors affecting the value of citrine.
Citrine Buying Guide
Since we already went through the Four C’s in pretty serious detail when we were discussing topaz, I’m going to give you the quick version here. I’ll describe how the Four C’s apply to the value of citrine, how to pick out the best stones, and which factors will help you negotiate a good price.
Before we start, I should remind you that citrine is a type of quartz, just like amethyst. When quartz has lots of iron in it, it displays beautiful purple colors and we call it amethyst. If the iron oxidizes, due to the right amount of heat and pressure, the quartz turns yellow, orange or gold and we call it citrine.
In nature, the conditions needed to turn amethyst to citrine don’t happen very often.
Citrine was actually quite rare until people learned how to artificially apply heat and pressure to amethyst (which is much more common) to turn it into citrine.
The vast majority of citrine you’ll see for sale was made this way. Pale amethyst turns yellow at relatively low temperatures, and orange to reddish brown at higher temperatures.
Naturally occurring citrine tends to be a lighter yellow than treated citrine, and reddish hues are usually a sign of treatment. Natural citrine is dichroic, displaying two distinct hues, while treated citrine is not. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) put out this excellent YouTube video explaining pleochroism. In an untreated citrine you would expect to see two colors.
There are also synthetic citrine gems that are completely manufactured by man. These stones are usually quite large, very cheap and perfectly clean with zero color zoning.
Always ask the vendor if the citrine is natural or synthetic. If it’s natural, ask if it’s been heated. Heat treatment is a very well accepted practice for citrine, and the color it produces is stable and will last. But this is a great way to find out if your gem dealer or jeweler is honest!
Remember, any ethical seller will always disclose gem treatments. If you find someone who insists their citrine is untreated, dig a little deeper. Maybe they do have a source of untreated citrine, but this is very rare and they should be able to document the origins of the stone. If they can’t, you should look for a more honest seller.
If you want to learn more about how citrine is heated and how to tell treated from untreated citrine, check out this great article by Hibiscus Moon. She is a science teacher turned energy healer, and she shares some fabulous photos, and also discusses how heating affects the energy healing properties of citrine crystals.
Let’s take a look at the Four C’s as they apply to citrine.
Color of Citrine: Citrine can be pale yellow, vivid yellow, golden-orange and orange-brown. Bright, bold colors are prized, with saturated golden-orange (called Madeira Citrine) being the most valuable. Natural citrine is typically pale to medium yellow. Any red or brown is a sure sign that the citrine is either heated or synthetic. Heating citrine is well accepted in the industry and does not lower the price of the stone.
Clarity of Citrine: Citrine is nearly always eye clean, even in large sizes. You should expect citrine to be clean, all the time.
Cut of Citrine: The same quality factors that we discussed with cutting topaz apply to citrine. Look for dazzling brilliance, avoid stones with empty or dark spots, and check the facets. They should come together in neat points, and the underside of the stone shouldn’t show any bulges.
Carat of Citrine: Because citrine is readily available in large sizes, the size does not affect the per carat price of the stone the way it does with topaz. You can expect to pay the same amount per carat for a 10 carat citrine as a 2 carat citrine.
You can see that clarity and carat weight don’t have much impact on the value of citrine.
The cut will make some difference, but with citrine the value really comes down to color. Look at as many stones as you can and figure out which hue you like the best. Then look for the most saturated citrine you can find in that color.
Durability and Wear: Citrine is not prone to chipping or breaking. It is a 7 on the Mohs scale, making it slightly softer than topaz. It is suitable for daily wear, though perhaps better for a pendant or earrings than a ring. That said, citrine rings are super fun, especially because you can often afford big, beautiful stones. If you go with a ring, just treat it with care. Take it off to do the dishes, and store it wrapped in a soft cloth apart from harder stones like topaz, sapphire or diamond.
Citrine Symbolism: The mystical history of citrine is very similar to topaz. It is associated with the sun and thought to bring abundance and joy as well as spurring generosity. Citrine has been nicknamed the “Success Stone” and the “Merchant Stone” for its ability to bring luck and prosperity.
Ametrine combines the ancient and modern November birthstones. If you’re interested in citrine you should also take a look at ametrine. Ametrine is half amethyst and half citrine, making it kind of a perfect November birthstone. It has amethyst, the ancient November birthstone from Aaron’s breastplate according to the original Old Testament translation, and it has citrine, the modern and popular addition to the November birthstone list. Plus, it is beautiful.
Where to Buy November Birthstone Gems
Buying imperial topaz can be a challenge, just because there are so few dealers handling it. The same is true for precious and pink topaz.
Fortunately, you already know someone with a pretty wide range of gorgeous, untreated precious, pink and imperial topaz for sale.
As I suspect you must know by now, topaz is my specialty. Through my online store, Lockwood & Sloan I sell all shapes, colors and sizes of precious, pink and imperial topaz. I work with a small, ethical mine in Brazil and with custom and precision gem cutters here in the States. I can track every stone from the moment it left the earth until it is sitting on your finger. Take a look. You’ll find that I have some really unusual and unique colors of topaz, fair prices and a commitment to customer service.
Of course, I’m not the only one selling topaz, and I encourage you to shop around and compare quality and prices. Remember the Four C’s.
Here are other quality sources you can check out for topaz, citrine, amethyst and all the alternate November birthstones:
Africa Gems is a good source for loose November birthstone gems as they have a huge variety of citrine and usually a dozen or so imperial topaz gems. They also carry garnet, aquamarine and amethyst if you decide to go the alternate November birthstone route. Africa Gems is a member of the AGTA, has been in business since the 80’s, and has a solid reputation in the trade.
Wild Fish Gems is devoted to quality. Their motto is: No treatments! No inclusions! No windows! They have some really fun and unusual cuts of citrine, with awesome colors. They usually carry a decent range of imperial and precious topaz, with fair prices and exceptional grading reports. And yes, they occasionally do sell a gem with inclusions, but they always describe them accurately and price them fairly.
AJS Gems deserves a strong mention. They have an amazing selection of gorgeous loose gems. AJS is based in Bangkok and imports gems from all around the world. What sets them apart is their devotion to quality cutting and honest trading. They’ve been in business for over 30 years, have a huge inventory and pride themselves on treating folks fairly. What more can you ask for in a gem dealer?
I have to include Constantin Wild here, as he has some of the most spectacular topaz gems on the planet. His stuff is truly, truly incredible. These gems are for serious collectors, or at least those with some serious loot to spend. Even if you’re not in the market for top end topaz, you have to look at his site, the gems are STUNNING.
If you are interested in going vintage, check out Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry. They have some sweet Edwardian and Georgian antique topaz jewelry, including some fabulous Russian pinks. They’ve also got quite a lot of pink topaz set with peridot, which is just so cool based on the intertwined etymological history of the two gems.
Levy’s Fine Jewelry also has some nice vintage pieces, a few featuring imperial topaz and quite a lot with citrine and amethyst. I especially love this ring, which features both and is an especially unique November birthstone piece.
Thank you for joining me to learn all about November birthstones. I hope I was able to answer all your questions. If there is anything I missed, or anything you'd like to share or add, please fell free to reach out to me directly at firstname.lastname@example.org. Cheers, and happy gem hunting!